Everyone’s talking about the Chinese spy. Everyone’s missing the bigger story
Few people are talking about a cancelled football star. Scandal is delicious, but silence is chilling.
We in the West might be tempted to dismiss the Mbappe episode. So what that footballer isn’t a favourite in China any more? The striker is still alive and (literally) kicking. Nothing especially dramatic has taken place.
But it has. China didn’t just silence one football player. It used access to its market to enforce its governing mythology on the world. The CCP delivered every organisation hoping to sell to the Chinese a warning that alternative narratives to its own will not be tolerated – even if they are trivial and take place outside China. Everyone hoping to interact with China has been warned that the truth must not be uttered. Every original punster with a cat named Mao is potentially committing a thought-crime.
It comes at a time when China has launched a charm offensive on X. Thanks to the wonders of AI translation, it’s now possible to have conversations with people from around the world who speak different languages. Chinese netizens are often witty. No-one living under a totalitarian regime would dare say anything that deviated from the party orthodoxy in such a public place, of course, but I believe they are genuinely proud of China’s considerable achievements. There is good reason to be. The West also has much to be proud of, including the freedoms we take for granted.
A popular clip from ABC TV’s satire on government, Utopia, asks why we should defend our trade routes against our largest trading partner. The Chinese government just told us why: because even trade with China is conditional on submission to values that are antithetical to pluralistic, democratic societies. And once we are sufficiently silenced, the Chinese government can walk in the front door to a more kinetic form of control. Installing a lock on the door at least reminds us that it could be needed.
