Summer is coming. Here’s what you should know about sharks
Last summer was one of the worst on record for shark bites. This Christmas, what can we do to stay safe at the beach? One survivor and two experts wade in.
Drones are another effective measure – in the right context, they allow us to see what’s really happening in the water. Drones show shark nets don’t work: you can see the sharks swimming over and under and around the nets. So the government’s investment in drones is, in fact, funding the largest study ever proving that the government’s investment in nets is ineffective.
Colin Simpfendorfer is an adjunct professor of Marine Biology at James Cook University. He is one of the world’s foremost scientific experts on sharks. From 2012 to 2020, he was co-chair of the International Union for the Conservation of Nature Species Survival Commission Shark Specialist Group – the leading global authority on the conservation, management and extinction risk assessments of sharks, rays and chimaeras.
“When we talk about shark-human interactions in Australia, we’re really talking about three species: white sharks, bull sharks and, to a lesser degree, tiger sharks. But mostly bull sharks and white sharks.
So for bull sharks, at this time of year they’re coming south from places like Queensland into NSW, sometimes even Victorian waters. The females are going into rivers – always the same river, often the place they were born – to give birth to their young. And the young bull sharks will live in those rivers for several years before they leave.
White sharks are a bit less predictable. This is a roaming species, and so the adults in particular can be anywhere between here and New Zealand, or all the way down to Tasmania. We’re talking about an apex predator: one of their characteristics is they have a massive range they travel over. There’s no point staying somewhere for a long period because they’d eat out all the food resources.
Australia works very hard to identify and manage our shark populations and our fisheries, and we do an extremely good job. And that’s important, because sharks are intensively fished in many parts of the world, including many of our immediate neighbours. This idea that “Oh, there are way more sharks now than there were” – that’s simply not the case for these species. White sharks, for example, are long-lived and have few young: we certainly haven’t seen a sudden explosion in their numbers. On the other hand, there are certainly more people in the water now than there have ever been – especially with things like sea-changers in northern NSW, where there are a lot of juvenile white sharks.
When it comes to shark-human interactions, the most fundamental thing for people to understand is that even in bad years, a shark biting a person is an extremely rare event. Given the millions of hours people spend in the water, and the fact that there are always sharks in the water, bites are really extraordinarily unusual. So the fluctuation of numbers we see – as with NSW last year, for instance – can actually be just random chance.
The number of encounters do seem to go through cycles – and we don’t fully understand what drives those cycles. Certainly things like temperature, food, water quality do play a role for sharks; for people, the numbers of swimmers, their behaviour, and their location may be factors. The “rogue shark” idea [of individual sharks that repeatedly bite humans] has had very little science done on it, which makes it hard to dispel scientifically.
My take is that it developed from this observation that shark bites sometimes occur in groups. But that’s more likely due to local conditions making sharks more common in a particular area than a single shark biting lots of people. The idea itself first emerged a long time ago, when abattoirs were discharging offal directly into the ocean and rivers in places like Cairns and Townsville.
Those conditions attracted many sharks, and groups of bites occurred.
Being conscious of conditions is one of the ways we, as individuals, can mitigate our risk. Swimming at dawn and dusk is probably a bad idea: sharks’ vision isn’t necessarily always great, and it’s worse in low light. Don’t swim in the middle of the school of fish. Don’t swim alone.
There are also a number of technologies that can help, at least theoretically. Many of them are snake oil, but there’s very good scientific evidence that some types of electrical devices reduce your risk. Not eliminate it altogether – but significantly reduce it.
[A study in Nature in 2024 found that two such devices reduced the probability of bites by 54 per cent across bull, white and tiger sharks.] The idea of those devices is to interfere with the shark’s electrical sense. Sharks have seven senses to our five: they have cells that can detect changes in water pressure along their bodies; and they can detect very small electrical voltages from the muscle movements of their prey.
If we interfere with that electrical sensitivity, it confuses them, so they pull out of [potential] bites, swim away, avoid the scenario.
So that’s all personal stuff we can do. Then there’s the question of deterrents at community or government levels. The first possibility is fully netted enclosures: keeping sharks and people separated by a physical barrier. Enclosures don’t catch or trap sharks – or anything else – they just provide a barrier in the water. They work well in calm water, but not in high-energy environments where you’ve got storms or waves.
Then you’ve got measures like [gill] nets or drumlines. If we take netting, the obvious question is, is it successful? That’s a good question. It depends on what your metric of success is. Does success mean nobody getting bitten by a shark, ever? In that case, it’s clearly not working. Has it reduced risk? Maybe. The science is very hard to do. What we have known for a long time that these nets will also catch turtles, dolphins, a whole range of different fish. They don’t catch necessarily a lot of them, but they can still have very big impacts on what are relatively small populations of some of these species.
‘At the beach, there’s always a shark somewhere not too far away ... It’s where they live.’Colin Simpfendorfer
The third type of protection is the shark cull approach. Is that effective? It certainly isn’t a panacea. What we do know is that you can never get rid of all the sharks; and the consequences to the environment would be devastating. You’re going to kill a whole lot of other things along the way, impact a complex ecosystem, and affect things you can’t even begin to predict – including things like commercial fisheries.
So in the end, the benefits of these deterrents are very hard to quantify, and the costs are clear. That being said, I think governments are starting to wake up to the fact that just going out and killing sharks isn’t the answer; many people don’t see that as the answer. What we’ve seen over the last decade or so are some changes towards lower environmental impacts, still with appropriate risk mitigation. Are those changes happening fast enough? Hard to say. People think science will provide the answer. Actually, science can advise, but it can’t make the decision. It would be nice to see some real, consistently science-based decision-making.
The reality is that, at the beach, there’s always a shark somewhere not too far away. It’s their environment. It’s where they live. It’s not that they’re coming to stalk you. They’re just going about their normal daily lives. So they swim along beaches. They hang out wherever. Ultimately, you can never eliminate risk 100 per cent if you’re in the water. Everyone has to reach their own accommodation of these very small risks. People will do the things they love, and they should. Ultimately, we all have to take responsibility for what we do.
Three world titles, a shark attack, and the deaths of his three big brothers: how triumph and tragedy have shaped Mick FanningSnake bite first aid: If you spot a snake in your yard, go inside and have a beerSleepless nights, family tension and bullets in his arm: Bondi hero Ahmed Al Ahmed one year on
Get the best of Good Weekend delivered to your inbox every Saturday morning. Sign up for our newsletter.


