Tricky trade-offs will show what Labor values most when we can’t have it all
From AI job losses to productivity and tackling climate change, public debate is awash right now with choices between incompatible goals.
Two years ago, the Productivity Commission made the point that one of the reasons productivity did not recover very well here afterwards was the fact those jobs had been saved. In America, jobs had been lost, businesses had died – meaning workers went to more productive parts of the economy. Here, relatively unproductive businesses survived. And the fact unemployment stayed low under the Albanese government also contributed to poor productivity, because more young, inexperienced workers are working.
This is only part of the productivity story. But it points to the far more potent questions hiding just behind an often sterile topic: what is the fundamental character of this country? During the pandemic and after, both Coalition and Labor answered: Australia is a nation in which we look after each other and prioritise jobs and social stability over market forces – and, yes, to some extent over productivity.
That trade-off is pertinent right now. We are living through a period in which cries for increased productivity dominate public debate. At the same time, unemployment is rising, as are living costs. And many of the “solutions” put forward to the productivity malaise, like making it easier for businesses to sack workers or keep their wages low, cut directly against those concerns. At a time when we can’t have it all, what do we prioritise and how? What are the qualities of this country that we prize most?
These are questions for us all – though ones we rely on governments to answer for us.
Public debate is awash with such choices right now, in which two incompatible goals seem to sit side by side. Climate Change Minister Chris Bowen is in Turkey this week, urging other countries to do more to tackle climate change; last week he was joined by Anthony Albanese. Meanwhile, Australia remains one of the world’s largest exporters of fossil fuels – a fact Labor largely skates past.

